Can surgery be avoided in rectal cancers?

Can We Avoid Surgery for Some Early Rectal Cancers?

Results from the OPERA Trial

For many people with rectal cancer, surgery has been the main treatment. While surgery can be very effective, it sometimes comes with lifelong changes, such as a stoma bag or changes in bowel, bladder, or sexual function. Doctors and researchers have been looking for ways to treat early rectal cancer while helping patients keep their rectum — what we call “organ preservation.”

The OPERA trial, a large international study, explored whether adding a special type of internal radiation (“contact X-ray brachytherapy,” or CXB) could improve the chances of avoiding surgery.


What Did the Study Do?

  • All patients first had standard radiation and chemotherapy (chemoradiation).

  • Then, patients were split into two groups:

    1. Extra external radiation (EBRT boost).

    2. Contact X-ray boost (CXB) — a short procedure where a small device is placed close to the tumor inside the rectum to deliver a high dose of radiation directly.


What Did They Find?

  • Better tumor shrinkage: Over 9 in 10 patients given CXB had their tumor completely or almost completely disappear, compared with about 6 in 10 in the EBRT group.

  • Higher chance of avoiding surgery: At 5 years, about 8 in 10 patients who received CXB kept their rectum, compared with about 5 in 10 patients in the EBRT group.

  • Best results in smaller tumors (<3 cm): Nearly all of these patients were able to avoid surgery with CXB.

  • Side effects: Some patients had rectal bleeding, but this usually improved over time. Long-term bowel function was generally good.


Why This Matters

This study shows that adding a CXB boost can help more patients with early rectal cancer avoid surgery — while still keeping the cancer under control.

It’s not suitable for everyone:

  • It works best for small, early rectal cancers.

  • Patients need very close follow-up (scans, scopes, check-ups) to make sure the cancer doesn’t return.

  • CXB treatment requires special equipment and trained teams, so it may not be available in every hospital.


The Bottom Line

For some people with early rectal cancer, there may be a real chance to treat the cancer and preserve the rectum without major surgery. If you have early rectal cancer and are interested in organ-preserving options, talk to your cancer specialist about whether treatments like contact X-ray brachytherapy might be right for you.

About the Author

Dr Wong Ru Xin

Dr Wong Ru Xin is a Radiation Oncologist at Icon Cancer Centre Singapore and a Visiting Consultant at Proton Therapy SG. She earned her MBBS from the National University of Singapore (Dean's List), and holds FRCR and MRCS qualifications. She completed specialist training at the National Cancer Centre Singapore.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may also like these